Disclosure: ExhibitView makes trial presentation software, so we have a stake in this comparison.
Many lawyers start with PowerPoint because they already know it. Others move to trial presentation software once the exhibit count grows. This guide compares the two by task, covers when each is enough, explains how to use both, and notes what courts say about slides and exhibits.
Key takeaways
- The tools do different jobs. An ABA Litigation article says PowerPoint decks are typically used in opening statements and closing arguments, while trial presentation software is typically used to display exhibits during witness examination.
- PowerPoint follows the order you built. When a witness goes off script, paging through slides or a file costs time, and the ABA article says paging through a document live burns time and makes the jury restless.
- The court’s rules decide what you may show, whichever tool you use. N.D. Ill. Judge Valderrama’s order says an exhibit that has not been admitted cannot be published to the jury, and it allows exhibits in opening only if both parties agree.
- ExhibitView Trial Presenter lists an exhibit library, witness folders, Hot Docs folders, side-by-side display and live markup, and ExhibitView says its desktop products are designed for Windows.
What does each tool do well?
|
Task |
PowerPoint |
Trial presentation software |
|---|---|---|
|
A planned, linear story (opening, closing) |
Strong fit. The deck is the plan |
Possible, but not the usual choice |
|
Showing exhibits in the order a witness reaches them |
Slower, since slides follow the order built |
Designed for it, with exhibit libraries and folders |
|
Calling out part of a document |
Needs a prepared slide |
Callouts and enlargement during examination |
|
Playing deposition video |
Possible with linked files |
Often built in, depending on the product |
|
Marking up an exhibit live |
Limited |
Often built in, depending on the product |
The first two rows follow the ABA article. The rest are general descriptions, and products differ. Ask any vendor to show the task, not describe it.
When is PowerPoint enough?
It can be enough when the presentation is short, linear and mostly yours: an opening, a closing, a timeline, a few demonstratives. The ABA article describes PowerPoint decks as typically used for openings and closings to keep the presentation organized and the audience engaged. It also warns that busy decks can be confusing and unhelpful, and that a well-designed deck can give the trier of fact a road map of the argument. N.D. Ohio’s guide for litigants says a laptop can show PowerPoint content on the courtroom monitors, and suggests extending the desktop so you can queue what you need without the room watching you navigate.
When does trial presentation software help?
It helps when the order is not yours to control. In a witness-driven trial, the next exhibit depends on the answer you just heard. According to the ABA article, trial presentation software is typically used to display and call out exhibits during witness examination, which lets a technician enlarge text or mark words so the trier of fact can follow. It also helps with large exhibit sets, side-by-side comparisons and video depositions. ExhibitView’s Trial Presenter page lists an exhibit library, witness folders, Hot Docs folders, full screen and side-by-side display, live markup and synchronized video depositions.
Can you use both?
Yes, and many trials do. The ABA article lists three common technologies at trial: PowerPoint, trial presentation software such as the products it names, and video impeachment clips. A simple split is the deck for openings and closings, the trial software for exhibits and clips. In a courtroom with a control panel, switching between sources can be a button press. N.D. Ohio’s guide says the touch panels let counsel switch from exhibits to video to multimedia presentations with the push of a button. Decide in advance who runs each source and where each hand-off happens. A run-of-show sheet keeps it clear (invented example):
|
Segment |
Tool |
Who runs it |
Hand-off cue |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Opening statement |
Slide deck |
Lawyer |
Lawyer begins with the first slide |
|
Direct of the first witness |
Trial presentation software |
Paralegal |
Witness takes the stand |
|
Deposition clip |
Trial presentation software |
Paralegal |
Lawyer says “play clip 3” |
|
Closing argument |
Slide deck |
Lawyer |
Lawyer says “let me summarize” |
What are the risks of each?
Both tools can fail, and the preparation differs. A deck takes time to build, and each late change means editing slides. A trial software library is prepared once, but someone has to learn to run it. The ABA article says using technology requires preparation, that practicing the examination with the technician and watching the video clips in advance are essential, and that the attorney should be ready to go with the paper record on a moment’s notice. N.D. Ohio’s guide adds practical points that apply to either tool: use a corded mouse or pointer, since wireless devices can be picked up by the courtroom microphones, turn off system sounds, and bring a backup laptop or disk.
What do courts say about slides and exhibits?
Rules differ, and some are strict:
|
Court |
What it says |
|---|---|
|
N.D. Ill., Judge Valderrama |
No exhibits in opening unless both parties agree, with requests two business days before trial. An exhibit that has not been admitted cannot be published to the jury, and demonstratives do not go to the jury room unless all parties consent |
|
Rule 107 |
An illustrative aid is not evidence, and the note says the rule governs aids at any point in trial, including opening statement and closing argument |
These come from each court’s published information. Confirm the current version before relying on them. Your judge’s orders can differ. The tool you pick does not change what the court allows.
How do you decide?
|
Your situation |
Likely fit |
|---|---|
|
Short bench trial or hearing, a few exhibits you know in order |
PowerPoint, or a PDF and a document camera, may be enough |
|
Jury trial, many exhibits, witnesses who may go off script |
Trial presentation software |
|
Video depositions at trial |
Trial presentation software, or a technician with one |
|
Strong opening and closing, plus exhibits |
Both tools, with a planned hand-off |
What is the checklist?
- You have read the judge’s rules on slides, exhibits and projection.
- You know which parts of the presentation are linear and which depend on testimony.
- Slides are plain, with one idea each.
- Exhibits you may need out of sequence sit in a library or folders, separate from the slides.
- You have chosen who runs each tool and rehearsed the hand-off.
- A PDF copy of each slide deck is available as a backup.
- You have tested both tools through the courtroom’s inputs.
Conclusion
Use PowerPoint for the story you control and trial presentation software for the exhibits that follow the witness. Read the judge’s rules on slides and projection first, decide who runs each source, and rehearse the hand-off on the courtroom’s equipment.
About ExhibitView
ExhibitView makes trial presentation software for lawyers and paralegals, including Trial Presenter for showing exhibits and video in court. ExhibitView says its desktop products are designed for Windows, and iTrial is an iPad app for presenting. A short call can show whether it fits your cases.
Book a 15-minute call with Bill
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you use PowerPoint in court?
Often yes, but the judge decides. N.D. Ill. Judge Valderrama allows exhibits in opening only if both parties agree, and its order says an exhibit that has not been admitted cannot be published to the jury. Ask your judge about slides in openings and closings.
Is PowerPoint enough for a jury trial?
For a planned opening or closing it can be. For witness examination with many exhibits, the ABA article says trial presentation software is typically used to display exhibits, since a slide order built in advance does not bend easily to testimony.
Do you need a trial technician?
Not necessarily, but practice with whoever runs the screen matters. The ABA article says practicing the examination with the technician in advance is essential.
Are slides evidence?
Usually not. Under Rule 107, a presentation offered to help the jury understand evidence or argument is an illustrative aid, not evidence, and it stays out of the jury room unless all parties consent or the court orders it for good cause.
Do you have to disclose slides before trial?
Often you do. The Rule 107 committee note leaves it to the judge to decide whether, when and how to require advance notice of an illustrative aid and Judge Valderrama’s order sets a two-business-day request for exhibits in opening.
Can you show exhibits inside a PowerPoint deck?
Some courts allow it for admitted exhibits and restrict it otherwise. Judge Valderrama’s order says an exhibit that has not been admitted cannot be published to the jury. Check your court’s rules.
Recent Comments